top of page

Review: West Side Story - Jack Cunningham Productions

4 hours ago
10 min read
Review: West Side Story - Jack Cunningham Productions

Society name: Jack Cunningham Productions

Show name: West Side Story

Adjudicator date of attendance: 5th of September 2026


My second show of the season brought me to the Déise county to see Jack Cunningham Productions’ ‘West Side Story.’ The Theatre Royal is one of my favourite theatrical spaces. In existence since the late 1700s, its unique ambience and rich history are almost palpable as soon as you set foot inside. It’s a theatre steeped in history and character and a wonderful setting for one of musical theatre’s most powerful shows. Cast and crew brought great energy to this production, with some really impressive moments throughout.


Front of house at the Theatre Royal is always a positive experience. There was a great sense of expectation in the foyer before the show. Everything appeared to run very smoothly, with the busy raffle and programme station efficiently managed and audience members were ushered to their seats without any fuss. It was a very well-organised and welcoming front of house operation which added nicely to the sense of occasion.


Jack Cunningham’s directorial vision was clear from the moment we entered the theatre, with gang members already on stage, interacting with one another. This gave us a world that already existed rather than one that only began when the show began. The set was used very well throughout, particularly its different levels and the depth of the stage was used well to create effective groupings and stage pictures. There was great tension throughout the Prologue and particularly during the Quintet, while the use of cast members to strike furniture and set pieces was clever and unobtrusive. There were a few areas where I felt further attention to detail would have strengthened an otherwise solid piece of direction. I did feel there was a loss of momentum right after the Quintet. Having built such excellent tension, I felt that the transition and slow build into the Rumble let some of that energy dip. Diction and projection from some principal performers also needed work. The passing of the toy jet from one child to the other was a lovely final image, suggesting that maybe all was not lost and that another generation might choose differently.


Mr Cunningham’s choreography was most impressive and at times quite euphoric. Storytelling through movement was always front and centre. The fight sequences were excellent, extremely well drilled but still appearing spontaneous and dangerous. The Dance at the Gym showed great technical ability and performance levels within the young cast. With such a large cast on the relatively intimate Theatre Royal stage, it occasionally became quite crowded and some of the choreography didn't have the space it deserved to breathe. ‘America’ was another highlight, with excellent work from the Puerto Rican girls. ‘I Feel Pretty’ featured lovely interplay and movement between Maria and the four girls and the Dream Ballet again showed a great blend of choreography and dramatic storytelling. ‘Cool’ was an outstanding number with superb energy and explosive movement. For me, ‘Gee, Officer Krupke’ was the standout number of the evening, with excellent comedy, character, and an infectious sense of fun.


The multi-talented Andrew Lane was in charge of musical direction, working with a reduced orchestration for what is an incredibly intricate and demanding score. For those more familiar with the musical requirements of the show, there were moments when certain colours and details were missed, especially within the brass and woodwind sections. Keyboards did a great amount of heavy lifting in filling those gaps, assisted by some very good support from the sound desk, while percussion was outstanding throughout. Mr Lane clearly understood the strengths of the musicians available to him and used those strengths intelligently to cover gaps and get the very best from the resources at his disposal. One of his greatest strengths was his connection with the performers on stage. He was constantly engaged with them and that connection paid off in some really strong ensemble singing. Overall, this was very good work from Mr Lane, both in managing the musical resources at his disposal and, particularly, in the confidence and support he gave his cast.


Jordan Bass gave us a believable Tony, playing him as an idealist but with enough of an edge for us to believe that this young man had once been the leader of the Jets. One of Mr Bass’s greatest strengths was his ability to tell the story through song. Mr Bass possesses a fine tenor voice but, just as important, he knows how to use it intelligently. He made sensible choices around some of the score’s more demanding vocal requirements. There was great intelligence to Mr Bass’s acting too. He was always in tune with the narrative throughout and thought processes were always clear. Diction occasionally needed attention, particularly in his emotional scene with Maria following the Rumble. A very strong acting performance from Mr Bass, well sung and, when needed, very intelligently managed vocally.


Susan Boyce brought a lovely earnestness and innocence to Maria. She also gave us a very believable journey as her world changed so dramatically. She had wonderful chemistry with Mr Bass. I really liked their “Te adoro” moment during the balcony scene. It was beautifully played by both, showing their giddiness and innocence as they fell in love. Vocally, Ms Boyce had a pure and extremely accurate soprano. ‘Tonight’ was beautifully sung, with her voice blending so well with Mr Bass’s. ‘I Feel Pretty’ allowed her to show real character, as well as navigating the vocal demands of the number. A beautifully sung and sincerely acted performance overall.


Jennifer White brought her considerable experience to bear in a confident portrayal of Anita. She had great stage presence and brought a real strength to the character. Her vocal work in ‘America’ was full of personality and character, in what was a very vibrant performance overall. It was in ‘A Boy Like That/I Have a Love,’ however, that Ms White really showed her vocal and dramatic abilities. There was tremendous emotion and conviction in her performance, and she worked really well with Ms Boyce in this powerful and emotional number.


There is no doubting that Conor Lyons is a very talented performer. He had excellent diction and projection as Riff and led confidently from the front in ‘Jet Song.’ Movement and dance were obvious strengths, and Mr Lyons performed the choreography very well, bringing his great experience and confidence to bear. I did feel, however, that some closer work with Mr Cunningham would have helped to maintain the gritty realism of the piece. At times there was a tendency towards overly performative physical gesturing. This definitely showed Mr Lyons’s excellent performance energy but, I felt, sometimes went against the rougher edge and authority expected from the leader of the Jets.


Seán Murphy took on the often rather thankless role of Bernardo, a character who is given very little opportunity for development before his demise at the end of Act One. In spite of that, Mr Murphy made quite an impression. He had strong stage presence and a very convincing physicality, looking the part as the leader of the Sharks. He was particularly effective during the fight sequences, especially during the Rumble, where he was completely believable as a young, streetwise hoodlum caught up in the violent confrontation.


Adam Cliffe played the role of Chino. It’s always an interesting journey for Chino, who starts on the periphery of things but is ultimately responsible for the final tragedy. Mr Cliffe handled that progression quite well, ultimately allowing the darker side of Chino to emerge as events descended into chaos.


Fionn McGrath gave a super performance as Action. He was full of pent-up anger, frustration, and violence. Mr McGrath was like a tightly coiled spring, and we never knew when he might snap. He brought great physicality and presence to the role. There was some nice subtlety to his acting choices too. Vocally, Mr McGrath was also excellent, driving the infectious energy of “Gee, Officer Krupke,” which was one of the real highlights of the production.


At just 14 years of age, Tadgh Galibert Foley is definitely a performer to watch. His portrayal of Baby John was excellent, capturing the character’s innocence so well. There was a very nice honesty to his performance. His lovely gesture of placing the shawl around Maria’s shoulders served as a beacon of hope in the closing moments.


Jack McGrath was a standout as A-Rab. Mr McGrath brought excellent presence and tension to all of his scenes. He was particularly impressive in ‘Cool,’ committing fully to the dynamic movement and physicality of the number and he was always a strong presence during ensemble scenes.


Ellen Jacob showed some very solid character work as Anybodys, with plenty of the bravado and boisterousness of the wannabe Jet, desperate to be accepted as one of the gang. There was great determination to her performance, and she captured that constant need to prove herself to the Jets very well.


Keith Flanagan gave a believable performance as Doc, with a natural warmth and decency which helped to provide a steadying influence against all of the volatility around him. There was a sincerity to his performance which made Doc a very believable character. Mr Flanagan was particularly impressive following the attack on Anita when that warmth gave way to anger and disgust.


Fionnán ‘Fatz’ Dunphy was perfectly cast as Lieutenant Schrank. He looked every inch the hard-nosed New York cop, weary and frustrated by the juvenile delinquents on his beat. His accent was excellent throughout and his strong physicality and authoritative stage presence meant that when Mr Dunphy arrived on stage, we knew he meant business.


There was good character work too from Phil Erskine and John Power as Officer Krupke and Gladhand. Mr Erskine displayed some good physical humour as Krupke, while Mr Power was a very distinctive Gladhand. I particularly enjoyed his grating laugh. It was a small character choice that went down very well with the audience.


There was strong support throughout from all featured characters, including Joe Shanahan, Mark Rellis, Anthony Finn, and Sam Horsfall, who all contributed very well to the story’s energy and believability. The Puerto Rican girls were equally impressive, with Charley Fitzgerald, Millie Sloan and Holly Grant bringing great energy and character to their scenes. Particular mention must go to Amber Searson as Rosalia, whose superb vocals in ‘America’ really stood out. I was also very impressed by the two youngest members of the cast, Con Kickham and Charles Ware Murphy as the young Shark and young Jet and I’m sure we will be seeing both young men taking on larger roles in the years ahead.


The ensemble was very strong throughout, especially in the choreographed sequences but also in some really nice ensemble singing. Vocally, they were at their best in the ‘Tonight Quintet’ and ‘Somewhere,’ where the quality of the ensemble singing was very impressive.


The simple but effective set worked extremely well in creating this gritty, urban world. The existing back wall of the Theatre Royal stage was used to fabulous effect, with its wonderful rough texture lending itself perfectly to the streets of New York. The fencing, fire escape and balcony added levels to the playing space, with the balcony in particular giving us a very effective backdrop for Tony and Maria’s iconic scene. Individual locations were suggested quite economically but very effectively, allowing us to move from the street to Maria’s bedroom, the dress shop and Doc’s drugstore without losing pace.


Stage manager Dylan Lawrence did a good job in keeping the production flowing smoothly. With much of the responsibility for moving pieces given to the cast, Mr Lawrence did very well ensuring that transitions were well choreographed and organised, allowing the action to move quickly from one location to another.


Lighting was excellent throughout and played a very important role in supporting the storytelling. Haze was used to great effect, with strong beams cutting through and creating some striking stage pictures. The gobo breakups across the floor added to the gritty urban setting. There was good use of soft-focus follow spot for some more intimate moments, especially during the balcony scene. However, follow spot work was a little shaky on occasion and there was also a tendency to catch the pelmet during these scenes, due to the height of the balcony. The operator’s familiarity with Bernstein’s score was wonderfully evident during ‘Cool,’ where the timing of the cues showed excellent musicality.


Sound was also excellent throughout, supporting both the cast and the reduced orchestration very well. Keyboards were brought forward intelligently when required to help fill some of the orchestral gaps, without becoming overly dominant. EQ levels were very well judged for both dialogue and singing and there was an excellent balance between voices and orchestra throughout. The vocal mix was good during ensemble numbers. Sound effects were appropriate and well timed and, overall, this was an excellent sound design.


Costuming was very strong throughout, with excellent attention to character and individuality. The Jets were immediately identifiable as a group without ever looking like they were in uniform. The same was true of the Puerto Rican girls, whose colourful dresses looked great. The different colours and patterned skirts worked really well with the choreography. Maria was simpler and more youthful in appearance, helping her to stand out from the other girls and Gladhand’s wonderful tank top was suitably comical. The Dream Ballet was very striking with cast in all white contrasting with Riff and Bernardo appearing in black.


Props were very well handled, with good attention to detail and authenticity. The jukebox, dartboard, and the various pieces of dressing in Doc’s drugstore were particularly effective and smaller details such as Tony’s authentic looking radio, the basketball and comic book all helped to create a very real world.


Hair and makeup were generally very well presented. Hairstyles were, for the most part, era appropriate, with some nice individuality among the female characters in particular. The flowers and hair accessories worn by the Puerto Rican girls added nicely to their overall look and Maria’s styling helped to underline her youth and innocence. One or two of the wigs could have benefited from a little more dressing to achieve a more natural appearance. The blood injuries in the second act showed good attention to detail.


It has been a real pleasure to watch Jack Cunningham Productions go from strength to strength over the years, and ‘West Side Story’ was, I felt, another step forward for this talented young company. The show was an ambitious undertaking but was tackled with great commitment by a young cast with super potential for the future. There will always be areas to develop and lessons to take from a production of this scale, but this is clearly a group determined to keep challenging itself and raising the bar. I look forward with great interest to seeing where that ambition and willingness to learn takes them next.


Pat McElwain


Gilbert Adjudicator 2026/2027


Comments


bottom of page