Review: Dear Evan Hansen - Clara Musical Society

Society name: Clara Musical Society
Show name: Dear Evan Hansen
Adjudicator date of attendance: 19th September 2026

Photos courtesy of Clara Musical Society
It was a pleasure to visit Clara Musical Society in their new home, the lovely Esker Arts Centre in Tullamore for their production of ‘Dear Evan Hansen,’ a powerful musical exploring themes of loneliness, grief, belonging and the influence of social media. I attended on opening night, following what must have been a most challenging day for the society. Due to Culture Night scheduling, Clara’s technical and dress rehearsals had to take place that morning. That, however, did not impact what was a deeply affecting, exceptionally well-acted production, which allowed the characters and their relationships to take centre stage.
Front of house was extremely efficient, with a lovely atmosphere in the foyer and a warm welcome from the team. I enjoyed a pleasant chat with members of the front of house staff and society committee before taking my seat. I was particularly impressed by the pre-show announcements, which included an appropriate warning about the show's sensitive themes and potential triggers. What struck me most was the warm, reassuring tone of the person delivering the announcements.
Alan Recks clearly had a very good understanding of the material and his direction was one of the great strengths of this production. What impressed me most was the attention given to the relationships between the characters. They felt like real people, with real emotions and I found myself completely caught up in their stories. Mr Recks made the sensible decision to keep the staging simple, allowing the focus to be firmly set on the characters. The available space was used very well, with some lovely stage pictures, but there was nothing overly complicated to distract from the storytelling. I loved the restraint shown in more emotional scenes. Nothing ever felt forced or overplayed. There was also great sensitivity in the handling of the show's difficult themes. Mr Recks obviously trusted his actors and allowed them the space to explore their characters without overplaying the emotion.
‘Dear Evan Hansen’ isn’t a show that requires elaborate dance routines, especially with such a small cast, but Lea Carroll made excellent use of the opportunities available. Her choreography was simple, fluid, and effective, with carefully considered formations and movement which always felt appropriate. ‘Sincerely Me’ was one of the highlights. The Act One finale, ‘You Will Be Found,’ was equally impressive, with strong formations and transitions building towards an excellent end to the first half of the show. What I particularly liked about Ms Carroll’s work was that she never felt the need for conventional dance routines simply for the sake of it.
Very much the driving force of the production, Alan Recks also took on the role of musical director, conducting from his keyboard as part of the six-piece band which was positioned on the stage. The musicians worked extremely well together, with Mr Recks himself making excellent choices of keyboard patches. Vocally, this was an exceptionally strong production, with excellent harmony work throughout. One area which might have benefited from more attention was the coordination between musical direction and stage management during scene changes. Occasionally, scene change music finished before transitions ended, leaving crew exposed. That very small point aside, this was impressive musical direction overall.
Rian Fitzmaurice Condron gave an outstanding performance as Evan Hansen, capturing the vulnerability and social awkwardness of this lonely young man so beautifully. His hesitancy, and nervous mannerisms were so well played, but what impressed me most was how natural it felt. There was never a sense of Mr Fitzmaurice Condron playing at being awkward. Vocally, he was superb, with a wonderful upper range and excellent control. ‘If I Could Tell Her’ was a particular highlight, with lovely comic timing as he struggled to express himself to Zoe. Every emotion felt genuine, without ever overplaying. We were always completely invested in Evan’s journey, even when his actions were difficult to justify. This, for me, was what made Mr Fitzmaurice Condron’s performance so affecting and so memorable.
I have seen Aoife Digan in a number of productions over the years, usually in comedy roles in which she has excelled. I was therefore particularly interested to see her take on a very different role in Zoe Murphy, and what a revelation she was. What impressed me most was the subtlety of her acting. Even when the focus was somewhere else, Ms. Digan was always thinking, listening, and reacting. Vocally, Miss Digan was equally impressive. ‘Requiem’ showcased her excellent range and control and ‘Only Us’ was quite stunning. Having enjoyed her wonderful comic abilities previously, it was a real pleasure to see her demonstrate such depth and intelligence in a demanding dramatic role.
Stephen Keegan took on the challenging role of Connor Murphy, the troubled young man whose passing sets the story in motion. Mr Keegan had very good stage presence and was vocally strong throughout. He clearly enjoyed the opportunities for comedy in ‘Sincerely Me’ and contributed very well to one of the most entertaining numbers of the evening. His vocal performance in ‘Disappear’ was also particularly strong. I would have liked to see a little more exploration of Connor’s darker side during his earlier appearances. To be fair, the opportunities are limited but a little more work here might have added to what was already a really fine performance.
Amanda Cunningham was excellent as Heidi Hansen, Evan’s hardworking single mother who does her best to provide for her son but struggles to communicate with him. Ms Cunningham is a wonderful actress, and I especially admired the thought and attention to detail she brought to the role. Every word had a purpose, and we could constantly see her thinking and reacting. Her choices were clever, often subtle, and always believable. She conveyed Heidi’s frustration and helplessness really well, along with her obvious love for Evan and her desperation to connect with him. Vocally, she was very strong. ‘Good for You’ was a real highlight, powerfully sung and acted. Her final scene with Evan was especially moving. It was a beautifully judged performance from an actress who understood the value of subtlety and restraint.
Sinéad Handy gave a very strong performance as Cynthia Murphy, a mother struggling to come to terms with the death of her son. She brought a lovely emotional range to the role, with excellent delivery of dialogue and very believable reactions. Vocally, she was very strong.
Joe Steiner gave a very solid and assured performance as Larry Murphy. Mr Steiner had excellent stage presence, and he shone especially in ‘To Break in a Glove’ both vocally and dramatically. He handled Larry’s growing connection with Evan very well. His emotional distance was well observed, and he was very in tune with the underlying tension in the Murphy household. A very strong portrayal from a very talented actor.
Cian Sweeney was outstanding as Jared Kleinman, Evan’s sarcastic, quick-witted friend who takes pleasure in making fun of pretty much everything. Mr Sweeney brought wonderful energy and personality to the role. He was completely believable as a cocky American teenager, always ready with a smart remark and enjoying the chaos around him. Vocally, he was strong, impressing in the excellent ‘Sincerely You.’ Occasionally, there were glimpses that Jared’s banter and sarcasm might have been covering up some insecurities of his own. Mr Sweeney had such a likeable presence on stage, and I believed every word he said. A wonderful performance.
Laoise Flanagan was excellent as Alana Beck. She presented an enthusiastic and sometimes overly intense student who completely threw herself into the Connor Project. Ms Flanagan gave a superb characterisation, with lovely attention to detail and natural delivery of dialogue. Vocally, she was equally strong, with an exceptional performance in ‘Good for You.’ A highly confident, well-rounded performance from a very talented performer.
The set was very minimalist, with pieces of furniture suggesting the various locations. And that’s all that was needed. Some very impressive visual elements were created with the use of excellent graphics projected onto the cyc. These graphics were central in representing the online world that drove the story, with scrolling social media feeds, messages, images, and overlapping windows. Projections were sometimes deliberately busy but never distracted from the performances. ‘You Will Be Found’ was particularly impressive, with graphics, movement and lighting combining very well in what was a standout moment of the production.
Stage management was in the very capable hands of Wayne Handy and his crew, who certainly had their work cut out for them. ‘Dear Evan Hansen’ is a very fluid and busy show, with lots of location changes and relatively little time to move furniture and props. For the most part, these transitions worked well. Inevitably, there were a few opening night hiccups, however, with technical and dress rehearsals having taken place only that morning, Mr Handy and his crew had an enormous amount to contend with, and the vast majority of changes were handled efficiently. Overall, a very respectable opening night effort from a hardworking crew.
Lighting was also very strong, with great use of colour, superb isolations and very effective use of the vertical LED battens framing the playing space. The rectangular pools of light appearing on the stage floor, one after another, as performers moved through them were a very striking device. They almost looked like illuminated corridors, guiding the characters across the stage. The rectangular shapes also seemed to echo the screens and the digital imagery used throughout the show. ‘You Will Be Found’ was a particular highlight, with a wonderful build of colour which reflected the growing sense of hope and optimism in the song.
Sound was exceptional throughout, and I cannot compliment the team highly enough. The six-piece band was superbly mixed, with excellent balance between instruments and lovely attention to individual lines, particularly the violin, when featured. The vocal sound was very impressive. Voices were warm and full, sitting nicely above the accompaniment and there was excellent balance between singers and band. Overall volume levels were very well set, and everything was all the more impressive given the limited tech time.
Costumes were very well chosen and appropriate to the setting. Evan’s trademark blue and white helped establish his awkward teenage appearance and Connor's darker, looser outfits suited his character. The Murphy family's clothing reflected their comfortable financial circumstances without looking overly formal. Heidi's work scrubs were another nice touch. What particularly impressed me was the attention given to costume changes throughout the show. There was a good sense of time passing, with characters appearing in different outfits as the story progressed.
Props were most appropriate, with lovely attention to detail. The Murphy family’s breakfast table was very well dressed, with crockery, cereal and other everyday items creating a convincing, lived-in setting. I liked Jared’s gaming chair, which he seemed permanently attached to, along with his video game controls. Evan’s backpack and the cast on his arm with Connor’s signature were nice visual touches. The baseballs and glove for ‘To Break in a Glove’ were perfect, and the Connor Project buttons were another nice touch. The devices used during ‘You Will Be Found,’ with light from the screens illuminating the cast’s faces, were extremely effective.
Hair and makeup were appropriate with a very natural look throughout. The younger characters looked convincingly like every day American teenagers and the adults were equally believable. Nothing was overly theatrical or distracting, which was exactly right for the production.
This was a show which will stay with me for a long time. Clara Musical Society should be extremely proud of what they achieved. The standard of performance was superb, but what impressed me most was the honesty of the storytelling and the relationships between the characters. It was a real triumph for the society and a production that all involved can be justifiably proud of.
Pat McElwain
Gilbert Adjudicator 2026/2027




Comments